Proving The Experts Wrong

(A version of this appeared on The Heart of The Matter on June 14, 2023.)

I like to go back and read the 25-page report.

The report is dated from the early 2000s and gives a medical history on my son and lists the tests the doctors administered. I’m barely a page into the report and my heart is already breaking. “The patient is still fairly young and needs intensive work in letter recall and reading. He’s experiencing problems with basic phonetic and decoding skills.”

When I get to this next part, I find that I always have to wipe away a tear. “He will have trouble reading Stop signs. He seems to be a strong listener, but he’ll never be able to enjoy a book, other than picture books, or function as a normal adult.”

If I close my eyes, I can still see the doctor sitting across the table emotionless and my wife and I feeling like we just had the life sucked out of us.

Finding the source

When our son was preschool-aged, we noticed that he had trouble recalling letters. We weren’t too worried. We figured that he was young and still had time, but when he got to kindergarten and then first grade, he didn’t get better. To add to the challenge, he complained about constant itching. He wore Under Amour shirts underneath his school uniform to help reduce the problem.

We took him to several different hospitals. The doctors feared the worst, everything from a brain tumor to cancer. They gave him tests and took blood samples, but they could find nothing wrong. Finally, we took him to Johns Hopkins Hospital in Baltimore. They pieced together the puzzle, figuring out that he was dyslexic. The itching was a simple sensory response to the challenges he was facing.

Diagnosing the problem

Dyslexia is a reading disability that affects the way students learn to read or interpret words or letters. It frequently includes difficulties in word recognition, spelling, and decoding, but does not affect general intelligence. Dyslexia impacts people differently, some dyslexics reverse letters, others have problems recognizing common sight words.

While grateful to John’s Hopkin in diagnosing the problem, we found that the doctor’s bedside manner left a lot to be desired. She gave us little hope for the future.

Turning the tide

We were frustrated, but we loved our son. Throughout the process to find out what was wrong, he never gave up. We certainly weren’t going to give up on him.

With the cause determined, we worked to get him the help he needed. We got him an Individual Education Plan (IEP) and increased help in school. We worked with him every night and, after a six-month wait, we were able to enroll him in a special program, called Orton Gillingham, that incorporated multi-sensory phonics techniques to help him with his reading and writing.

Other kids got to go out for travel soccer or baseball, my son spent his free time training his brain. He was tired after school, but he worked year-round for an hour or two each night. He soon started to see the benefits, his grades started improving and he started to read on his own. One of my happiest memories was the day he came home from school complaining about a small detail that he had read in one of the Harry Potter Books that had been left out of the movies.

His progress soon started coming in bunches. When he got to high school, he continued to challenge himself. His teachers didn’t always know what to do with him. On one hand, he had an IEP that touched on the dyslexia and his papers usually had a few misspellings, but on another he was taking on harder coursework and college prep classes that posed challenges for even the strongest of students.

He went on to graduate high school and complete his freshman year of college. He brought home A’s and B’s, but opted to take a break and set out on a different path. That was five years ago — in the years since he enlisted in the Armed Forces and plans to eventually return to college.

The letter I’ll never send

With everything I know now, I occasionally like to pull out that old report. When I do, a small part of me wants to write the Johns Hopkins doctor and give her a piece of my mind. I want to tell her how her heartless attitude stole our hope. I want to tell her how my son wrote his college essay on Matterhorn, a 600-page novel based on the Vietnam War, and now regularly reads wonky policy and philosophical books. I want to write and say “See what you missed! See where you were wrong!”

In the same breath, I want to write her and thank her for identifying the problem. Like anything, once we had a name, we were able to attack it.

In the end, I move on.

Instead, I read the report and then I look at how resilient my son has been and all the things that he has accomplished in his life. They return my faith in humanity.

We’re writing about resiliency this month on HoTM. What’s the word mean to you?


Discover more from Writing from the Heart with Brian

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

39 thoughts on “Proving The Experts Wrong”

Add yours

  1. I’m sobbing. My son is Autistic. I come across the binders of test results from the early days. We were urged to place him in a “home” at age 5. Today? He’s 28, an honorary volunteer firefighter (helps out at firehouse with my husband – serves on committees), and is a monitor at our Middle School in the state retirement system earning a pension. I often think of calling the speech therapist who told me about the home option and screaming at her. Instead, I just smile and thank God for pointing us all in the right direction.

    Liked by 2 people

    1. Oh, thank you Kiki. My wife is a special ed teacher and we often say that several of her student’s parents from over the years were our inspiration for fighting for our son. It proved to us that . . . you need be open to what the experts say, but trust your own heart. You know best. And so much credit to your son. Just think if you listened to that speech therapist. Just think how different his life and your life would be. Ugh. Thank God you didn’t listen!!!!

      Liked by 2 people

  2. I understand how scary that must have been for you to not know why your son wasn’t reading. My daughter had a similar issue with reading that was diagnosed in elementary school as Irlen Syndrome or Scotopic Sensitivity Syndrome. It’s not recognized as being real like your son’s disorder. Our daughter had trouble focusing on reading, extreme light sensitivity and headaches especially under fluorescent lights which the school had. I’d find her in her bedroom doing homework in the dark. She’d skip words and lines when reading out loud. It was a struggle.

    Liked by 2 people

    1. It was a real struggle, but he’s a huge reader now. Stuff that most of us probably wouldn’t find all that enjoyable — philosophy and military books — but he loves it. After serving in the Marines, he’s going back to get his degree now. He’ll never be a great speller, but he’s doing well. Just sees things differently than others. Ha, ha.

      Like

  3. Any updates on your son’s progress, Brian. By the way I was told by my high school advisor that I should not go to college but consider a vocational track. Was a heartbreaker for me, but made me work harder. Undergrad degree and an MBA made me want to write the letter you described. Instead I thought about how wrong she was and how much of a gift she gave me.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. I really should update the end of this story. I wrote it my son’s senior year of high school. Our son is very modest, but he graduated high school, spent a year in college and did well, but wanted to serve in the Marines. He was always attracted to the service and physical part of it. He just got out after 6 years, earning the rank of Sgt and is going back now for his degree. He says it’s a little hard going back with everyone else in his class being 18-20 year olds, but he’s doing well. For someone that wasn’t supposed to read, he’s a voracious reader. Reads philosophical and military books. He’ll never be a great speller, but like you wrote it’s made him work harder and appreciate things. Thanks John!

      Liked by 1 person

  4. This was the week ending inspiration I need, Brian. It made me teary. You and your wife never gave up on your son and that love undoubtedly gave him fuel to also never give up on him. Congrats to your son and the proud parents for the wonderful man he’s grown up to be.

    Liked by 2 people

  5. What an inspirational story, Brian. Part of the problem is that many children weren’t identified as having dyslexia years ago. That doesn’t mean more children have it now; it simply means we know so much more about it now. They slipped through the cracks. Not only was reading hard for them, but it was a miracle if their self-esteem remained intact.

    One of my all-time favorite children’s middle-grade books is called Fish in a Tree. https://www.amazon.com/Fish-Tree-Lynda-Mullaly-Hunt-ebook/dp/B00KWG61P0/ The main character is a girl with dyslexia who goes undiagnosed for many years. She purposely gets in trouble to avoid the embarrassment of having to read in front of her teachers and classmates. It isn’t until a special substitute teacher enters her life that things begin to change, using a multisensory approach.

    If you want an uplifting read, I highly recommend you get this book.

    Liked by 2 people

  6. Brian – so much of this resonates with me – as a parent, I often think of the doctors who stole hope from us when Jessica was young. As a grandparent, one of our grandchildren is currently receiving tests for dyslexia. Your essay was reposted at a great time. Thanks for sharing your personal story; you have touched many people today – V

    Liked by 1 person

  7. What a powerful testimony to the danger of confusing a diagnosis with a destiny. The experts could identify the difficulty, but they could not measure your son’s determination, the persistence of parents who refused to give up, or what years of faithful effort could accomplish. There is a profound difference between saying, “This will be difficult” and declaring, “This will never be possible.” Sometimes the most important thing we can give someone facing a mountain is not false assurance that the climb will be easy, but hope that the mountain does not get to decide how far they can go.

    To me, that is resilience. It is not pretending the obstacle isn’t real, nor is it never becoming tired or discouraged. Resilience is refusing to let what is difficult become the final definition of what is possible. Your son did not prove that dyslexia wasn’t a genuine challenge; he proved that a genuine challenge does not have to have the final word. What a remarkable journey—and what a reminder to be very careful about placing a period where someone else’s story is still being written.

    Liked by 2 people

    1. I agree with you. I think the doctor nailed the issue. He definitely had some learning challenges, but she failed to look at his his heart. That’s what always bothered me . . . she made a broad statement that I suspect for many people would’ve taken away their hope. His resilience was a God send in high school, throughout his six years in the Marines and now going back to get his bachelors. Thanks Kimberly.

      Like

  8. That is wonderful! Whoohooo! 🙂 … When I was 33 (2000), I had a huge stroke. My family and most my friends etc. were rooting for me to get better, but some other people thought, ‘When you have a stroke you have 6 months, and then you will not get any better.’ …. HELLO??!! It took me 7 months until I could read a full sentence. 🙂

    Liked by 1 person

  9. This is such a beautiful testament to parental love. I’m thrilled to read that your son has done so well! Though I’ve been following your blog for some time I never knew the back story. Wishing you and your son much happiness now and in the future. xxxooo

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Yea, I’ve written some, but not a ton about my son’s dyslexia and everything that he has overcome. He’s accomplished so much since then. He’s graduated high school; served six years in the Marines, earning the rank of Sergeant; and is going back now for his bachelors. Spelling still causes him some issues, but he reads these deep, deep books like War and Peace that put my reading list to shame. I have to admit that I would write more if he would let me, but he doesn’t view it as a big thing. I try to respect his privacy, but my fatherly pride in him comes out sometimes and gets the best of me. Ha, ha. Thanks Lori for the kind comments, I appreciate it.

      Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Website Powered by WordPress.com.

Up ↑

Discover more from Writing from the Heart with Brian

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading