When asked in studies and surveys over the years, readers almost always say they want authenticity. It’s Communications 101: people want real stories from real people. They don’t want plastic, they don’t want fake—they want the real thing.
Corporate America of all places actually learned this decades ago. In 1969, Coca-Cola launched one of the most successful advertising campaigns in history by positioning Coke as the original, authentic cola: “It’s the Real Thing.”
And in the years since, master storytellers—from Dolly Parton and Bruce Springsteen to Stephen King and Anthony Bourdain and many others—built entire legacies on that exact same promise. You don’t grow up in a small one-room cabin without electricity or running water, build a net worth estimated between $500 and $650 million, and remain as universally beloved as Dolly Parton before she died without knowing a thing or two about connecting with people.

But… really?
I can’t help but wonder sometimes if readers actually know what they’re asking for. Do they really want all the unvarnished truth? Or do they just want a polished, curated version of it?
The truth is, raw authenticity isn’t neat. It can be downright messy. I think how my own life can run the gamut from swinging from a hardened cynicism that borders on deep negativity to a sappy, overly dramatic optimism. I can be dry sarcastic one minute and downright cornball the next.
I’m a walking study in whiplash. It’s like I’m parked along the side of the road and get nailed from behind—except instead of my neck, it’s my entire personality taking the impact.
Let’s Get Real
Take a recent day: I started one morning this past summer wiping away a tear over a sappy dad video on my phone. Aww, isn’t that cute? That dad saved the day. You go, Dad! You make all of us dads proud!
Then I ended that exact same day—during a 14-hour airport delay—slinging sarcastic quips to anyone within earshot. “Yeah, take that, American Airlines! You suck!”
Um, hello, same day. First instance Dr. Jekyll. The next Mr. Hyde. Yikes.
A Terror On The Road
Or take last week on the road: I threw my hands up in exasperation when a driver pulled out in front of me without leaving room to stop. Oh, I managed to jam on my brakes in time, but I was not happy. I didn’t offer a single-finger salute, but I did hold my hand out, palm up, asking ever so kindly: What the heck are you doing?
Then, that very evening, I absentmindedly pulled the exact same move on the guy behind me. Oops, excuse me, sir. Well, I didn’t actually say that out loud, but I meant to say it if we ever bumped bumpers.
Um, hello Robert Louis Stevenson and your novella The Strange Case of Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde, move on over for Brian, a real mess.

The Gritty Truth Or Not?
My point is, I think most of us are a crazy collection of good and bad, coexisting in the same person. Real life doesn’t come with a carefully rehearsed script or a polished brand guide. If authenticity means showing up in all our messy, contradictory, whiplash-inducing glory, maybe that’s what writers owe their readers—whether they’re entirely ready for it or not.
I know I try, but I also don’t want to be a Negative Nancy, a Debbie Downer, or swing too far the other way into Pollyanna Bobby with my rose-colored glasses and an attitude that says, “Oh, isn’t this ketchup sandwich grand?”
What about you?
Are you looking for neat, polished stories, or do you prefer the raw, whiplash-inducing truth? Drop a comment below—I promise not to judge your driving. (At least, not out loud or online in my blog!🤣)
Images by Pexels.
Discover more from Writing from the Heart with Brian
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

We are all a delicate balance, but we are few who see it in our own self. Great way to start the week!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Just be yourself, right Sharon. Ha, ha, thanks.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Wow, Brian. you just nailed the truth. Head-on. We are “a crazy collection of good and bad.” And I’ve just been thinking about this very thing regarding my posts. I often write “neat, polished stories”, but I’ve got that cynical side too. I’m just very hesitant to use it in writing because I don’t know how it will land. I once posted a “funny” story (I have a strong sense of humor, sometimes it’s “different”) and saw a couple of readers did not appreciate it. It was just me showing the other “side” of me; both things can be true! Thank you so much for showing that you got angry with the airlines, but can be “Pollyana” and mean it, too. I vote for “raw, whiplash-inducing truth” because it IS the truth. I love this post.
LikeLiked by 3 people
I’m with you Melanie. I like to be polished too, but I also know that I’m sarcastic as hell too. I find that I see humor in places that others don’t always see it. I worry about that occasionally, but I’ve also come to the conclusion that readers need to take me as I am. If they don’t appreciate or like my humor — well, so be it. I don’t mean that in a bad way. I like readers as much as the next writer, but I have to be myself. I can’t be another writer. I’m going to gain some readers that way and I suspect I may lose some too . . . kind of like life. For example, I had gone to a funeral a few years ago for a family member and wrote a piece afterward where I used a line that I knew might raise a few eyebrows. I forget the exact line but it made fun of the crazy nature of funerals – how we want the clock to stop, but life still goes on. I remember having my wife read it first because I knew it wasn’t very deferential. I ultimately kept it and actually got a lot of positive feedback for showing warts and all. Who knows what readers will like or won’t like? ha, ha.
LikeLiked by 2 people
“who knows what readers will like or won’t like?” That comment alone brings confidence. We DON’T know. I love that you got positive feedback for keeping it real. I’ve always prided myself on having an authentic voice, and I know that it is, but I hold lines back, soften the edges; avoid writing about certain topics. It’s probably a Sally Fields thing “I want people to like me!” haha. I’m seeing that I should be 100% me, and keep my fingers crossed. This is so fascinating, thank you, Brian.
LikeLiked by 2 people
The Sally Field thing is natural. We all want to be loved/liked. One of the areas I know I’ve censored myself in recent months has been family pieces when I write about my dad. When I was young, he had a lot of anger issues. I know that still shows up in my anxiety-worrying. Later, when my kids were born, we were closer but I still have things I feel I need to say. My mother is still alive though and I hate to upset her so I’ve definitely pulled back in areas. I’m with you though. It’s a process!!!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Ahh. I understand and of course you don’t want to hurt your mom. Perhaps, one day, you’ll know the time is right, because you are right. You need to say the things you need to say. Thanks for an interesting conversation, Brian.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I want the truth. All of it. I need to know that I’m not alone in this world. Not one soul LIVING on this planet is perfect. I’m here for all of it so let it fly!
LikeLiked by 4 people
Love that perfection line Kiki!!! So true. But, damn, the thanks for bursting my bubble! I thought I was Mr Perfect. You mean I’m not!! Ha ha. I’m with you — let it fly!!!
LikeLiked by 1 person
lol ok no one except you is perfect! How’s that! Lol hope you had a great day!
LikeLiked by 1 person
I totally relate. I feel like I have been going through whiplash the past week with my dad almost dying and I have a difficult relationship with him. It brings out the best and worst in me.
LikeLiked by 2 people
Awww, sorry about what you’re going through. That’s gotta be hard.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thanks. Like you said, it feels like whiplash. Especially my reactions.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I’m all about the truth – plain and simple.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Yes, yes, yes!!
LikeLike
What a breathtakingly honest and brilliant post, Brian! The comparison between craving polished stories and living through daily emotional whiplash is so spot on. 😊
LikeLiked by 2 people
Honesty wins!!!! Ha ha.
LikeLiked by 1 person
We’re all complex people – and to your point, we experience and can also exhibit the good and the bad and everything in between. I think I prefer someone being real in the moment, whatever that means, in their writing. That authenticity does stand out and come across.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thanks for joining me on the ride Ab — warts and all!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Oh geez. Me, too! I’ve done that exasperated huff with other drivers when I’m cut off and then find myself committing the same crime, without intending to be rude. Same reaction as you, Brian. Whoops! Sorry! 😜
LikeLiked by 1 person
Oh but I’m sure you were nice as pie Vicki! Me … a raving lunatic!!! Ha ha.
LikeLiked by 1 person
🤪❤️🤪
LikeLiked by 1 person
I’m used to whiplash! Give it all! LOL!
We are ALL messy. I’ve never wanted to appear “Pollyannish” because overall, I’m a very positive person. My twin could tell stories of some of my WORST experiences in life and I’d always say, “Could be worse!”. Which is true. But I don’t ignore the sucky parts, either.
I think our stories, through many of them, can show the layers of us. Some are fearful of exposing any layer. One reason I’m no longer on Facebook is because of the things that are posted. I’m not being judgemental. It’s just that I would rather read authentic stories–the good, bad, and ugly–rather than repeated and shared memes or over-filtered lives that only what a screen-shot version of life? If that makes sense?
My emotions can swing in a day. But that doesn’t mean my soul isn’t grounded. We’re just human. With emotions! And I appreciate and value all the layers of you, my friend! Keep em coming!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Real stories not the fake ones. Love that!
LikeLiked by 1 person
🥰🥰
LikeLiked by 1 person
I can go from Pollyanna to Sarcastic Suzy in 2.5 seconds. I don’t know, I also thought it was a gen x thing. As far as how real I want it from others? Depends on what day it is and what ny mood is.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Do you think that’s a Gen X thing or a Philly Thing?? We were hanging with my wife’s Philly relatives this weekend and definitely saw some of both!!! Ha ha!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Hmmmmm…good point. Maybe a little of both. Because I haven’t lived in Philly since I was a kid, but went to see my relatives all the time. You can take the girl out of Philly, but you can’t take the Philly out of the girl. That jawn just stays in you forever.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Ha ha, love it. When my wife slips into “wooder” or refers to the ack-a-me… I always have to laugh or joke that Billy penn is coming down from city hall to remind her where she grew up! 😎😎😎
LikeLiked by 1 person
Lol
LikeLiked by 1 person
Oh, you landed this, Brian. We are “a crazy collection of good and bad, coexisting in the same person.” Funny how we want all the good emotions and a filter on the “bad” ones. I think I just lean to listening when someone offers a good dose of perspective, just like you’ve done here!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Whiplash!!!! Ha ha.
LikeLike
Brian, I think most of us want authenticity right up until somebody actually gives it to us. Then suddenly we’re standing there thinking, “Whoa, whoa, whoa…I meant authentic with good lighting and a little editing!”
Personally, I’ll take the emotional whiplash. Give me the person who tears up over the dad video in the morning and is composing an entirely different sermon for American Airlines by evening. That sounds suspiciously like the rest of us.
And the driving example may be the most authentic part of the whole post. Nothing develops mercy toward the driver who just cut you off quite like realizing five minutes later that apparently YOU are now the driver who cuts people off. There’s a humbling little life lesson delivered at 45 mph.
I think authenticity isn’t spilling every thought we have onto the page—it’s refusing to pretend we never have those thoughts in the first place. We can be grateful and grumpy, compassionate and cranky, wise one minute and wondering who left us unsupervised the next. The polished version may photograph better, but the real version is usually the one that makes somebody on the other side of the screen say, “Oh good. It’s not just me.”
So yes, bring on the real thing. Just maybe keep Pollyanna Bobby and his ketchup sandwich at a safe distance. I have standards. LOL
LikeLiked by 1 person
When readers say “Oh good. It’s not just me.” … one of the best compliments you can get as a writer. Love that.
LikeLike
Great piece and so true, our authentic selves is such a hackneyed phrase. It’s a phrase used so glibly. Only one person was true to His Word always.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Gotta be true to ourselves. Thanks for reading.
LikeLike
At least we are each burdened with only two distinct personality traits. Pity those who have multiple personality disorders. BTW I’m schizophrenic and so am I.
LikeLiked by 1 person
That made me laugh! Love it.
LikeLike
Glad I could make you smile.❤️
LikeLiked by 1 person
I most certainly want the unvarnished truth when it comes to memoir. I appreciate any author who puts it all out there, particularly if some of the details don’t paint the best picture of them.
LikeLiked by 2 people
Unvarnished truth!!! Love it.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Life is not only full of contradictions, it thrives on that tension. It is our destiny to navigate through this maze and find our own paths forward. Thanks for sharing, Brian.
LikeLiked by 1 person
My mantra lately …. Life is full of complications, live with it. Ha ha.
LikeLike
See, that’s why I try to give other drivers grace instead of the single-finger salute: I have inadvertently done the same thing myself, and it doesn’t mean I’m a bad driver or unnecessarily reckless. Now, if I could just get Tara to adopt that same philosophy! Her middle finger is super buff because of the workout it gets.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thank you for listening??!!!
LikeLiked by 1 person
You’re observations of how we can span a huge spectrum of emotions in a very short time. Happens to me, too.
For my reading and entertainment, I tend to like the gritty. Is it more real than the sappy? I don’t know. I just know that I’m a drama diva. I don’t create drama in my wake (though I know some who do) but I like exploring the harder, darker sides of life. Give me a good Auschwitz story and I’m, um, well not happy, but satisfied with what I read or watched.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I hear you. I say all the time I want “to be moved” — meaning you don’t care if it’s a thought, a laugh, or a tear. I want to feel something! 😎😎😎
LikeLiked by 1 person
HA! Whiplash it is! That’s what makes us human – but most people don’t think about it as you did so creatively today! The time I gave a finger salute, the angry driver got out of his car and blocked traffic – I screeched my tires and drove around his car to safety. I learned my lesson – now I wait until I am out of visual range before giving the finger!!!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Oh how scary! That sounds awful. I would’ve gotten out of there too!😎😎😎😎
LikeLiked by 1 person