A bad boss’ impact on mental health

I watched my boss through his plate glass window office. I had already put in a 12-hour day, I was tired and frustrated. I had spent the day working on my piece for the next day’s newspaper and he was making wholesale changes. 

I was all for edits, I loved good feedback, but his changes often made little sense and were done without much thought or consideration to style or tone. When he was done, he handed it back to me with a huff and went back to his desk. 

I made his changes and then left for the day exhausted and beaten. When I pulled into my apartment complex, I was confused on how I had gotten into this strange situation. I hated my job, it took everything to get up and out of bed everyday and go into work, but my home life couldn’t get any better. I loved my time with my wife.

Managers and our mental health

I’ve had more than a few moments like that in my life. I saw a report this week that helped give the problem some context. A new report from the Workforce Institute shows that managers impact employees’ mental health (69%) more than doctors (51%) or therapists (41%) — and at the same rate as a spouse or partner (69%). Other reports from other firms have reported similar findings.

I’m not surprised by the numbers. It makes sense that managers and bosses would have a significant impact on your life, but it was interesting for me to see the figures in black and white and see how much of a role a bad manager can have on our lives.

In my own situation, I was newly married and extremely happy, my time in the evenings and weekends were heavenly. I couldn’t wait to get home to my wife. At the other end of the spectrum, I hated my job. My boss cared little about anyone else, his actions rarely matched what he promised, and I could never give him what he wanted. 

An uneven scale

I tried to keep my two lives separate, a barrier so-to-speak, but work caused more than a few unnecessary headaches. My wife commented on how nervous I seemed to be over little things. Of course, I was worried constantly about my boss blowing up on me and work. I guess I’m not alone in work challenges seeping over into home. In the report, 43% of employees reported “often” or “always” being exhausted, and 78% of employees said that stress negatively impacts their work performance. That stress from work carries into our personal lives, with employees reporting work negatively impacts their home life (71%), wellbeing (64%), and relationships (62%). 

My wife was wise enough to see the source of my unhappiness, but it still caused some early tension in our marriage. Fortunately, I wasn’t in the job long. My wife was experiencing her own work challenges and we decided to move back to Pennsylvania. I hated resigning from the job, because it took a long time to get and I had worked hard, but it felt good leaving a bad job behind and turned out being one of the best decisions we ever made.

We put each other’s happiness over work.

Images by Fauxels via Pexels

29 thoughts on “A bad boss’ impact on mental health

  1. Good to read that you had an understanding and loving wife who supported you through these times, Brian. There seems to be a western business culture which favours profit over welfare for workers. I experienced many managers who were promoted on the basis of connection rather than competence, during my working life. The pandemic has made people realise there is a balance to be had between work and home. Hopefully the balance is starting to tip back to less work and more play.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. You’re right Davy. These bad bosses got their job because of closeness with their supervisor or because they were a subject matter expert but didn’t know how to manage. A person may know the job well, but that doesn’t mean they know how to manage and get the most out of people. YOu’re right too about the pandemic’s influence in helping people to see the importance of balance. I know it’s influenced me. I take the financial loss then stay with a bad manager. It’s too much of impact on my health and mental state. Thanks so much for commenting!

      Liked by 1 person

  2. You made a good decision, Brian life is too short to put up with an abusive boss or other negative work environment. We had a somewhat similar situation at one point in our lives and made the collective decision to move back. Best decision we ever made. And so very fortunate when you can make that decision together.

    Liked by 2 people

    1. Oh, yes, work matters, but it can’t be the only thing. I’ve had great bosses and I’ve had horrible ones. I’ve never felt bad about leaving a bad boss. You gotta worry first about your family and your own health. Life is too short! Thanks for the great advice Jane. Appreciate it.

      Liked by 1 person

  3. Thanks for sharing, Brian…so many things running through my head! Most of all, the importance of taking care of yourself. Workplace animosity seems on the rise, based on observations of my clients’ experiences…and it’s hard to watch/witness when I know there are better, more collaborative and supportive leadership avenues. Such a topic! Thanks for posting about it. 😔

    Liked by 1 person

  4. Wow, I am so glad that you guys have such a strong marriage! I have worked for some real jerks myself and have walked out on them. Employees always deserve better.

    Liked by 1 person

      1. Exactly! The last job I had was in 2016, I worked for a retired military guy who was younger than me at U Haul. He seemed to think that he was still in the military by the way he basically bullied me around.

        I gave him a warning shot across the bow one day and told him I didn’t like the way he treated me. He backed off for a while then started up again. When that happened, I went to the office and told his wife, the other manager who was very nice that I am resigning. I have self-respect and dignity. Bye!

        Nobody deserves that crap.

        Liked by 1 person

  5. Oh Brian, I can relate to this more times than I care to admit. 😫 To deal with it, although you carry “their” messes home even when you didn’t want to, were great stressors. I learned that (1) They weren’t qualified for the job; they just loved the title of being addressed a boss (2) They didn’t have the “Manager” type of mentality and discipline. They were the ones with the problems. We were the trash can they dumped their insecurities on. SMH 😲😱😖 Great post!

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Yes, yes, yes, Kym. You are so right. I think the funny thing for myself any way is to look at my performance for bad managers versus good ones. When I’ve been fortunate to have a great boss, I’ve run through brick walls, worked to turn water into wine, and went out of my way to have things done right. A great boss makes all the difference in the world. (I’m convinced that the work matters less than the boss. If I have a great boss, I could be counting widgets and I would be happy. If I have a bad boss, one hour doing that would feel like a decade. Ha, ha.)

      Liked by 1 person

      1. Oh my goodness Brian, you nailed it, and I feel the very same way! Bad vs. Good can make a heck of a difference mentally, emotionally and physically. When I found myself teetottering on ungodly thoughts, 😲 God either moved them out, or moved me in a different direction. Yes! 😊🙏🏼🤗

        Liked by 1 person

  6. I had to learn the discipline of leaving work at work and not bringing it into our home space. Mrs. Chess was much better than I at that skill early on in our relationship, and she helped me in being able to throw that switch and put work “on the shelf” until it was time to go back. I have had my share of horrendous and wonderful supervisors alike, and certainly on more than one occasion wondered how in the world they got a leadership role in the first place. Happiness > Work!

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Yup, you’re right about discipline. Keep it at work. I’ve learned a lot from younger coworkers, but one area where I’ve resisted over the years is blending work and home. I’ve made some accommodations there, but I never wanted to bring home a bad job to my family. It comes home naturally, but I didn’t want to add to the problem. Great advice Bruce, thanks for commenting.

      Liked by 1 person

  7. The statistics are frightening. I wouldn’t think it would be that high, but work takes a big chunk out of your day! My daughter had a job preCOVID that she loved in marketing for a sports company. But the they hired a manager that she couldn’t stand. He would tell her to do things she was uncomfortable with like call a publication and ask them to change a headline, editorial or photos in a news story already published. She knew that a new site wouldn’t do that, but she had to make the call or be yelled at. Then the manager went through her work and asked her to make changes on press releases that had already gone out and resubmit them! Like you said, they were changes that made little sense. Unfortunately, or fortunately, COVID hit and most of the company was laid off including her and that manager.

    Liked by 1 person

  8. Work life balance is so important and a good manager recognizes the importance of their team’s wellbeing and its impact on performance too.

    Liked by 1 person

  9. So fascinating to see the numbers on the impact of bosses versus other people. Wow! Yeah, bad bosses and/or work environments really impact our lives.

    Thank goodness for your lovely wife and that you got out of there. As you noted, it’s hard to do when we are invested in the job or work, but given the numbers you’ve about the impact to the rest of life, necessary so as not to affect everything else.

    So interesting! Thanks, Brian!

    Liked by 1 person

  10. My last “formal” job has excellent health benefits, fantastic perks, meals purchased once a week, and a promised opportunity for growth when I took the position. It happened to fall right in place with my degree. Nothing could have been better. Or should I rephrase that? One teeny-tiny impactful strain was still unaccounted—my supervisor. Her superior loved me and even gave me extra assignments. It wasn’t easy being a single mom and earning my keep while standing out above the rest. But I did it.

    Three years in, working so many hours of overtime that one day I went home at my regular time and someone asked me if everything was okay! I finally was recognized and was notified of the position opening that had initially brought me to the company. The pay increase was nearly double! I had no doubt I could do the job; that’s what the big time studying at school and the office had prepared for me.

    My mistake? During my time in the trenches, I’d relayed to my supervisor how alike we were. Sure, I am her senior and White, but we’re both single with two kids, so I relayed this info. Immediately, she told me how this place offered her the first job she’d had and promoted her up to where she is now by the age of twenty-eight.

    Not wishing to waste too much of your time with details, I interviewed a total of four times. I’d met the people I’d be working with, and we’d set up a time of a ride-along so I could see the process. EXCEPT he wanted to speak with my supervisor. Just like that, the ride-along was canceled and I didn’t hear another word from him.

    The next day, my supervisor informed me that her supervisor, who had assigned me additional work, was not there anymore, and there was no point in continuing my work in that direction any longer. Nearly four months of work was wasted. Then she had me learn and test on processes the company no longer utilized. I was done, and she was going to make sure I learned every process while she conveniently strolled behind my desk and watched me work.

    Finally, I couldn’t take it any more. Now, I’m taking a variety of educational programs and searching for a way to utilize them for my own promotion.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Aww, that sounds horrible. Especially going so far (four interviews) into the process. What a horrible experience. I’m sorry to hear that. Hence, my story a great boss really does make all the difference in the world. A great one makes your day, a bad one makes you want to quit and never come back. Good luck with the education programs to help you where you want to go!

      Liked by 1 person

  11. Hello! I am a licensed therapist that is starting a new journey on YouTube and WordPress. I was browsing others that are helping the community and talking about difficult topics. I really enjoyed this post because it is so relevant. Even I have experiences some really unfortunately management and I’m in the mental health industry so you’d think they’d be more aware of their impact. We spend so much time at work that I can see how our boss has such a large impact. You’re doing a great job and I wish you lots of growth and happiness. Enjoy your day.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Yes, I’m not surprised that even the Mental Health Industry has problems with bad management. My example in the post was a communications role and, of course, my manager couldn’t communicate with his employees to save his life. Pretty sad! Good luck on your journey. There’s definitely a need for it. I know I associated my worth through my job for too many years. I think workers have gotten smarter about this, but, even in remote environments, it’s still a challenge. Good luck with your practice and thanks for reading.

      Like

Comments are closed.

Website Powered by WordPress.com.

Up ↑